Day by Day Cartoon by Chris Muir

Showing posts with label Hobby Lobby. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hobby Lobby. Show all posts

Sunday, July 6, 2014

The Hobby Lobby Decision Demystified for Your Liberal Acquaintances

From Ace of Spades HQ:

Something that most people, who vote Democrat, don't get. Someone has to pay for it.

Their entire schtick to that it's "free", what ever "it" is, as long as the Democrats in power aren't paying for it. However, sooner of later, OPM (other people's money) runs out.

Saturday, July 5, 2014

Hobby Lobby's boycotters aren't crafty enough

From Instapundit:
Culture warriors face two additional problems:

They tend to want to boycott places they never shopped at in the first place.

The company’s actual core demographic takes umbrage about the boycott and stages a much more effective counterboycott.

I can’t tell you how many times I have had some version of the following conversation:

Angry person on the Internet: Wal-Mart’s treatment of its workers is shameful. I am not going to give that company any of my business!

Me: How much did you spend at Wal-Mart before you realized its treatment of workers was shameful?

The modal answer to this query is sudden disappearance from the conversation. I’m not sure anyone has confessed to spending as much as $1,000 a year at the stores. Of those who claim to shop there, most seem to do so almost entirely on vacation in rural areas.

If this describes you, you are not Wal-Mart’s core demographic, and its executives don’t care whether you boycott the business; the loss in sales is less than they experience from miscalculating what sort of sunscreen to buy. They care very much about what their core demographic thinks, but those people are, by and large, not interested in these boycotts; they’re interested in paying 12 cents a can less for tomatoes.
Indeed.
I suspect this is the case with Chick-fil-a as well.

Friday, July 4, 2014

Democrats were in favor of religious freedom before they were against it

From The American Thinker Blog:
Democrats and their allies in the mainstream media are in a dither over the Supreme Court Hobby Lobby decision. And driven by either agenda or ignorance, they don’t even remember that at one time they were all champions of the same religious freedom they are now against.

The SCOTUS ruling is not about contraception, but instead it affirms a law dating back to 1993. The Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA) is a law, “to protect the free exercise of religion,” according to the U.S. Senate. Specifically, the purpose of the law is “to provide a claim or defense to persons whose religious exercise is burdened by government.” That is the crux of the Hobby Lobby claim. Congress passed this law almost unanimously.

The RFRA was introduced following an unpopular SCOTUS decision curbing the religious freedom of Native Americans to use peyote. Congressman Charles [Chuck the Schmuck] Schumer introduced the bill in March 1993, a time when liberals were strongly in favor of religious freedom. The bill was cosponsored by many of the same Democrats braying the loudest about the SCOTUS decision, including Rosa DeLorio, Luis Gutierrez, Nancy Pelosi, and Maxine Waters. The Senate passed this bill by a vote of 97-3. Voting in favor were Senators [Joe "Bite Me"] Biden, [Babs] Boxer, [DiFi] Feinstein, {Dingy} Reid, and Mikulski among many others. {Editor's Note: And signed into law by President Bill Clinton]

What a difference a couple of decades makes. Harry Reid was in favor of religious freedom before he was against it. Voting for the RFRA in 1993, he is now indignant that the SCOTUS upheld the same law he voted for. Ditto Nancy Pelosi, who is fussing about “a gross violation of workers’ religious rights.” What religious rights are being violated? Are the Hobby Lobby workers members of a religion with a commandment, “Thou shall be provided abortifacients paid for by someone else”? Or is it the employer whose religious rights are being violated – “Thou shalt not kill” – by making him or her purchase these drugs for employees?

Hillary Clinton also found the Hobby Lobby decision “deeply disturbing.” How ironic that her husband, in November 1993, signed the RFRA into law, and when upheld 20 years later, she finds it disturbing.
Intellectual consistency has never been a strong suit of the Democrat Party. or the Drive-By-Media. or Liberal/Progressive Activists.

Thursday, July 3, 2014

Liberals’ Hobby Lobby Doublethink

From Jonah Goldberg of National Review:

If birth control is “not your boss’s business,” why do you expect him to pay for it?

Abortion-rights protesters gathered outside the Supreme Court building on Monday holding signs that read “Birth Control: Not My Boss’s Business.”

Much to their chagrin, Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito agreed in his ruling in the Hobby Lobby case.

Of course, that’s not how supporters of the government’s contraception mandate see it. They actually believe that birth control is their boss’s business, and they want the federal government to force employers to agree.

More on that later, but it’s first worth noting how we got here.

First, contrary to a lot of lazy punditry, there is no Obamacare contraception mandate. As my National Review colleague Ramesh Ponnuru notes, even President Obama’s liberal rubber-stamp Congress of 2009–10 never addressed — or even debated — the question of whether companies can be forced to provide contraceptive coverage. Department of Health and Human Services bureaucrats simply asserted that they could impose such a requirement.
............................  
Moreover, Hobby Lobby never objected to covering birth control per se. It already covers 16 kinds of birth control for its employees. But it objected to paying for what it considers to be abortifacients, which don’t prevent a pregnancy but terminate one. The pro-abortion-rights lobby can argue that “abortion” and “birth control” are synonymous terms, but that doesn’t make it true.

One lesson here is that overreaching can have unintended consequences.
As has been said before, but not by the activists, the Hobby Lobby case was never about denying women ACCESSS to birth control, it was about who was going to PAY for it.

Tuesday, July 1, 2014

6 Stupid Arguments About Hobby Lobby From Dumb Liberals

From The Federalist:

1) The Supreme Court is denying access to birth control.

2) The Supreme Court is discriminating against women.

3) The men on the Supreme Court shouldn’t be allowed to rule on decisions that affect women.

Good call, Harry.

...............

5) The Supreme Court decision just proves that GOP wingnuts want to control my bedroom.

6) Your boss shouldn’t make health care decisions for you.


This entire case can be summarized with this single tweet.

What Does the Left Think the Supreme Court Is?

From Charles C. W. Cooke at National Review:

Hobby Lobby exposes mass incomprehension of the role of courts in a constitutional republic.

Conspicuously absent from yesterday’s post-Hobby Lobby hullabaloo was the acknowledgment on the left that the decision was the product of a court. Distilling into a single line what was a popular and widely disseminated critique, the New York Times’s Nick Kristof tweeted a picture of Justices Kennedy, Roberts, Scalia, Thomas, and Alito, sardonically labeling the quintet as “The experts on women’s health on the Supreme Court who ruled today against contraception coverage.” A few hours later, Senator Harry Reid’s office pushed out an assessment that was cut from the same unlovely cloth. “It’s time that five men on the Supreme Court stop deciding what happens to women,” Reid tweeted.
.....................

The justices are jurists not doctors — they are nine appointed attorneys whose role in the American settlement is to provide legal answers to legal questions. Man or woman; straight or gay; handsome or ugly; Jew, Catholic, or protestant — the law must remain the law, regardless of in whose name its intricacies are decided. The alternative would be disastrous. Does Harry Reid aspire to see Roe v. Wade, which was decided by nine men, overturned?
I wish someone would ask Dingy Harry that question.

Hillary deeply disturbed that Supreme Court upheld statute signed into law by her husband

From Hot Air:
Thanks to AG Conservative for that headline. First “don’t ask, don’t tell,” then DOMA, now RFRA: Precisely how many statutes signed by Bill Clinton are the Clintons currently horrified by?

It’ll be fun during President Hillary’s administration to try to identify the various laws that Senator Chelsea will be forced to repudiate circa 2036.
Hillary must be the most tin-eared politician there is out there running for President. Any other would have been shammed into quitting.

Birth Control Can Cost As Little As $3.77 Per Month

From Breitbart's Big Government:
While Democrats attempt to use the U.S. Supreme Court’s Hobby Lobby decision as a political weapon against Republicans, the fact is women can purchase birth control for as little as $3.77 per month.

Writing at his blog called the Self-Pay Patient, Sean Parnell, author of a book by the same name, helps people who are paying for their own healthcare to find avenues for the highest quality, inexpensive options. His latest post addresses purchasing birth control.

Neither Parnell nor this author are claiming to endorse artificial birth control, but while the Obama administration tries to whip uninformed women into a frenzy about how Republicans don’t want them to have birth control, it’s good to revisit how easy and inexpensive it is for women to purchase it on their own.

“The first (and pretty much only) thing for people to understand is that shopping for birth control pills as a self-pay patient is no different than shopping for any other sort of prescription medicine as a self-pay patient,” writes Parnell.
The case was not about denying women ACCESS to birth control, it was about a case of whether an employer would be FORCED to provide it.

Monday, June 30, 2014

White House Spokesman -- "The Constitutional Lawyer in the White House" Disagrees with the Supreme Court

From the Washington Free Beacon via Ace of Spades HQ:
White House spokesman Josh Earnest said the “constitutional lawyer in the Oval Office” disagreed with the Supreme Court’s assessment of religious freedom Monday during his daily press briefing.

The Supreme Court ruled Monday in favor of the Christian-owned company Hobby Lobby, saying by a 5-4 vote that Obamacare’s mandate that companies pay for insurance coverage for contraception violated its religious freedom.

“There are now a group of women of an indeterminate size who no longer have access to free contraceptive coverage simply because of some religious views that are held not by them, necessarily, but by their bosses,” Earnest said.
Typical Liberals, they want someone to pay for their stuff.

Sandra Fluke on Hobby Lobby -- 'A Woman's Boss Should Not Have a Say'

From Joel Pollack of Breitbart California:
Sandra Fluke, whose campaign for free contraception elevated her to national prominence while she was still a law student at Georgetown University, denounced to the Supreme Court's 5-4 decision in the Burwell v. Hobby Lobby case: "A woman’s boss should not have a say in her health care decisions," Fluke stated on Twitter.

Fluke seems to have misunderstood--or miconstrued--the case. Hobby Lobby sued precisely because it did not want to have a say in, or be forced to pay for, the private contraceptive decisions of its employees. The company, which is run according to the owners' religious principles, objected to contraceptives that act as abortifacients.

Similarly, CNN's asked Hobby Lobby's attorney, Lori Windham, why she wanted to "bring the employer into what should be a very private decision-making process between a woman and her doctor." Windham's response: "Hobby Lobby would love to stay out of this, and leave this decision to a woman and her doctor."
Fluke's logic process can be summarized below:

Supreme Court Strikes Down Obamacare Abortion Pill Rule as Violation of Religious Liberty

From Ken Klukowski of Breitbart's Big Government:
WASHINGTON, D.C.—Today in Burwell v. Hobby Lobby, the Supreme Court of the United States ruled that a key regulation in President Barack Obama’s signature health care legislation is illegal as applied to millions of Americans of faith, as well as their businesses or organizations.

In Obamacare’s second round before the nation’s highest court, Justice Samuel Alito wrote the opinion in the 5-to-4 rebuke of the Obama administration for violating the individual rights of American citizens, holding the so-called HHS Abortion Pill Mandate violates religious liberty protected by the Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1993 (RFRA).

Obama’s beleaguered Affordable Care Act includes a requirement that all employers offering insurance must make “preventive care” part of their healthcare package. The White House decided that the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services would issue a regulation declaring “preventive care” includes numerous forms of birth control, including at least four that cause abortions in pregnant women.
Birth COntrol and Abortion causing drugs are NOT part of Obamacare. The requirement to include this coverage as part of Employer provided healthcare was a regulation by HHS, it's not part of the law.

SCOTUS rebuked the Administration over the 1st Amendment and the Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1993 (RFRA), which was signed by Bill Clinton.

Boom!